The Relationship We Used to Have
The person is right here, and still, something is gone: the shared memories, the thought partner, the banter. A couple of members named the grief of missing the relationship they used to have. Everyone recognized it, and no one quite knew what to say.
A couple of members talked about a grief that everyone in the room recognized, and that no one really knew what to say about: missing the relationship they used to have.
You can look across the table and see the same person. Your best friend. Your life companion. Your mother. The face is the same, and on some days so is the smile. But they may no longer remember the memories you made together. They may no longer be your thought partner, the one you talk a decision through with. The sounding board is gone. So is the banter, the shorthand, the joke that only needed a look.
The Little Cuts
What makes this grief so hard to describe is that it rarely arrives as one big loss. It comes as little cuts.
Turning to tell them something, and remembering. Making a decision alone that you would always have made together. Hearing a story you both lived, retold without you in it. Laughing at something they would have loved, and having no one to share it with, even though they are in the next room.
Each one, on its own, seems too small to mention. Together, they snowball. And because each one is small, there is never a moment when it feels permissible to stop and grieve.
Why No One Talks About It
There are a few reasons this grief stays so quiet.
It can feel disloyal. They are still here. How can you grieve someone who is sitting across from you?
Other people often cannot see it. They see the person, looking much like themselves, and assume the relationship is intact. A short visit may never reveal what is missing.
And there is no event. No date, no service, nothing to send a card about. The loss just keeps happening, a little at a time.
Pauline Boss gave this experience a name: ambiguous loss, grieving someone who is physically present but psychologically or emotionally changed, with no clear ending and no closure. We have written about it before, in The Loss Before the Loss. The research on couples living with dementia describes it in very ordinary terms. A study of older men caring for wives with dementia found they were gradually losing their couplehood: shared everyday routines, intimacy, joint activities, meaningful conversation, and their dreams for the future (Stefánsdóttir, Munkejord and Sveinbjarnardóttir, Scandinavian Journal of Caring Sciences, 2021). Another study, of spouses whose partners had moved into long-term care, found that the feeling came and went. Spouses moved back and forth between loss and belonging, with brief glimpses of connection that felt real but did not last (2014 qualitative study).
That back-and-forth is familiar. It is not only spouses, either. Adult children lose the parent who was their advisor. Friends lose the friend who knew them longest.
What Is There to Say?
Maybe very little. And maybe that is all right.
What seemed to help in the room was not advice. It was being heard, and seeing heads nod. Nobody tried to fix it, because it cannot be fixed.
A few things some caregivers have found useful, offered as possibilities:
- Naming the specific losses. Not “I miss him,” but “I miss being able to ask him about the car,” or “I miss our Sunday crossword.” Naming the small things can make the grief feel less vague, and less like something you are imagining.
- Letting it count as grief. It is grief, even though no one has died. It deserves the same gentleness.
- Noticing the moments of them. Sometimes the person you knew surfaces for a moment, as we talked about in Fleeting Moments of “Them”. Those moments can be a gift and a wound at the same time.
- Holding both relationships. The relationship you have now is real, and it may still hold love and tenderness. That does not erase the loss of the one you had. Both are true.
If you are missing someone who is still right here, you are not alone in it, and you are not being disloyal. You are grieving.
Where We Have Been Before
- The Loss Before the Loss, on anticipatory grief and ambiguous loss.
- Grieving What Was (Again and Again).
- Honoring the Small Losses.
- A Different Loneliness, on the particular loss when it is your spouse.
- Speaking to Someone You Used to Know as an Equal.
- When Relationships Change.