7 min read

Doubting Yourself Is the Definition of Caregiving

One member shared that caregiving has worn down her self-confidence, because of all the problems she can't solve. Self-doubt isn't a side effect of caregiving exhaustion. It is one of the things that exhaustion is made of, and the research says the tiredness is real.

Someone in the room said it, and nobody argued: doubting yourself is the definition of caregiving.

It came up early, during check-in. One member shared that her self-confidence has been worn down by caregiving. Not by one big mistake, but by all the problems she cannot solve. She is a capable, thoughtful person who has solved problems her whole life. Now she lives with a steady supply of problems that have no solution, and over time that has started to feel like evidence against her.

Exhaustion ran under nearly everything said that hour. All I want to do is crawl in a bed. It’s impossible to ignore the drag. Tired all the time. And one line that sat heavy in the room: I can’t quite accept that exhaustion is the price to pay for being a caregiver.

We wanted to spend real time on how those two things connect, because they do. Self-doubt is not just something that happens when we are tired. It is one of the things the tiredness is made of.

This Is Real Tiredness

Many caregivers carry a quiet worry that their exhaustion does not quite count. They did not run a marathon. They sat in waiting rooms, made phone calls, cooked, watched, listened, and thought. Why should that leave them this drained?

Part of the answer is that thinking, the way caregivers think, is work the body pays for.

In a 2022 study published in Current Biology, researchers in Paris gave two groups a full day of mental tasks, one set demanding and one easy. By the end of the day, the group doing the hard thinking had a buildup of glutamate, a byproduct of brain activity, in the prefrontal cortex, the part of the brain that handles planning, judgment, and self-control. That buildup seemed to make further effort more costly, and people in that group began leaning toward choices that took no effort and no waiting (Cell Press, via ScienceDaily). The researchers’ working idea is that mental fatigue may be the brain protecting itself, a signal to stop before the buildup does harm.

That study involved about six hours of computer tasks, not caregiving, so it is an illustration rather than a direct measure. But it puts a name to something many of us know. If you reach late afternoon and cannot decide what to make for dinner, that may not be a failing. It may be a brain that has been working hard all day, asking to stop.

A Mind That Never Closes the File

Caregiving thinking has a particular shape. Members described versions of all of these:

  • Hypervigilance. Listening for the fall, the cough, the change in breathing. Reading a face for signs. Never fully off duty, even while asleep.
  • Second-guessing. Did I give the right dose? Should I have called the doctor yesterday? Was I too short with her this morning? Each decision gets made, then reviewed, then reviewed again.
  • Problems with no solution. The illness will not be fixed. The decline will not reverse. A mind built to solve problems keeps turning them over anyway, because that is what it knows how to do.
  • Not being able to stop. Knowing that no matter what you do, the person you care for is not going to get better, and continuing to give everything anyway. Caring is not something a person can switch off.

One way to describe this is cognitive overdrive: a mind running at high speed for months or years, with no point where the work is checked off as done.

Second-guessing deserves special attention, because it doubles the work. A caregiver’s decisions are rarely made once. They are made, then lived with, then argued with afterward, often at 3 a.m. Self-doubt is the voice that keeps reopening the file. It can turn one decision into three, and a night’s sleep into a review session.

Not Knowing Is Its Own Weight

Research on uncertainty helps explain why this wears us down so much.

In a 2016 study at University College London, volunteers played a game in which they might receive a mild electric shock. Stress was highest not when a shock was certain, but when it was a toss-up. People sweated more and their pupils widened more when they did not know what was coming than when they knew a shock was on its way (UCL). Being sure of something bad was easier on the body than not knowing.

Caregiving lives in the toss-up. Will today be a good day? Is this a new symptom, or nothing? Was that the right call? Is the next phone call the one? There is rarely a clear answer, and almost never anyone to tell us whether we got it right. Self-doubt grows easily in that soil, and the body registers the uncertainty as stress all on its own.

From the Mind Into the Body

Long-term stress does not stay in our heads. Researchers use the term allostatic load for the wear and tear that chronic stress leaves across the body’s systems: hormones, heart, metabolism, immune function.

A scoping review of studies on family caregivers of adults with chronic illness found that caregivers carried a higher allostatic load than people who were not caregiving, and that caregiver burden, felt stress, and that physical wear tended to show up together (scoping review summary, JoVE).

An earlier study followed spouses caring for a partner with dementia, some new to it and some long-time caregivers, for two years. It found that how stressed people felt predicted part of the body’s stress response better than the outward demands of their situation did (Psychology, Health & Medicine).

This is a big part of why self-doubt matters. It is not “just in your head.” The steady inner pressure of wondering whether you are doing enough, or doing it right, is exactly the kind of stress the body keeps track of.

Where the Confidence Goes

A national U.S. study of more than 2,600 family caregivers looked at what researchers call caregiving self-efficacy, a caregiver’s confidence in their ability to handle what caregiving asks of them. Lower confidence went along with more pain, more sleep problems, and more difficult emotions, and the link between confidence and both pain and depression was stronger for women (Chang, Seo and Von Visger, Innovation in Aging, 2020).

That is a correlation, and it probably runs in both directions. Poor sleep and pain wear down confidence, and worn-down confidence makes rest harder to find. But it puts our member’s experience on solid ground. Losing confidence is not a separate, private problem sitting on top of caregiving. It is tangled up with how tired our bodies are.

There is something else worth naming. Caregiving often measures us against problems no one could solve. If the scorecard is did they get better, every caregiver loses, every day. The group did not try to talk anyone out of their doubt, and we won’t try here either. But some caregivers find it steadying to notice what their confidence is being measured against. Showing up, noticing, advocating, adjusting, trying again tomorrow: these are things a person can do well, even when the illness keeps winning.

The Price We Can’t Accept

Back to the line that stayed with all of us: I can’t quite accept that exhaustion is the price to pay for being a caregiver.

We don’t think anyone has to accept it. Exhaustion may be what caregiving is costing right now and still not be a fair price, or a permanent one, or a sign that something is being done wrong. Both things can be true at once: I am this tired, and it should not have to be this way.

The doubt and the drag are what it looks like to care for someone with everything you have, inside a situation that offers very few clear answers. The tiredness is real. It has causes. And you are not alone in it.

Where We Have Been Before