How Is the Caregiver?
Most of us hear 'how are you?' tens of thousands of times in a lifetime, and mostly as a greeting. Then we become caregivers, and the question quietly changes to 'how is he doing?' Everyone in the room had felt that shift. We looked at what the research says about the question, and about who stops asking it.
Everyone in the room had noticed it.
At some point after becoming a caregiver, people stop asking how you are. They ask about him. They ask about your mom. How’s she doing? Any news from the doctor? It is kindly meant, and it is often the only question that comes.
The group named a few things that might be going on underneath. Sometimes it seems the person asking will measure how the caregiver is by hearing the update on the care recipient, as if the two were the same thing. Sometimes it seems they feel that asking about the care recipient covers both of you. Either way, the caregiver disappears from the conversation a little at a time.
A Question We Hear Constantly
We wanted to know how often people hear this question over a lifetime, and how often it is meant as a real question.
Nobody seems to have counted the question itself. The closest figure comes from the other side of the exchange. A survey of 2,000 adults in the UK, commissioned by the Mental Health Foundation, found that the average adult says “I’m fine” about 14 times a week, and that only 19% of them mean it (OnePoll for the Mental Health Foundation). The same research found that:
- 59% expect a less than honest answer when they ask someone how they are.
- 34% say “I’m fine” because it is easier than explaining how they really feel.
- 23% say it because they don’t think the person asking is really interested (The London Economic).
As a rough back-of-the-envelope estimate: 14 times a week is more than 700 times a year. Across an adult lifetime, that is somewhere above 40,000 times. That is a rough figure from one country’s survey, not a precise count, but the scale is the point. We are asked constantly, and both sides mostly understand it is not a real question.
A Greeting Shaped Like a Question
Linguists have a name for this. Phatic communication, a term from the anthropologist Bronisław Malinowski in the 1920s, describes talk whose job is to make a connection rather than to exchange information. “How are you?” is a greeting shaped like a question.
But it is not quite empty. A well-known study in Language in Society looked at how older adults answered a routine “how are you?” at the start of interviews about their medical experiences. People did not treat it as meaningless. In the moment, they were negotiating: is this a greeting, or are they really asking? How much should I say? (Coupland, Coupland and Robinson, 1992)
That is exactly the decision the room was describing. Every time someone asks, a caregiver has a split second to work out which question it is.
When the Question Changes
For caregivers, the research suggests the question about us really does fade, even in the places where it would matter most.
A study of nearly 2,000 family caregivers of older adults in the US found that only 28% said health care workers always or usually asked whether they needed help. For caregivers of people living with dementia it was 37%. Yet 89% said those same health care workers usually listened to them (Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, on Wolff et al., JAMA Network Open, 2020). We are heard about the patient. We are rarely asked about ourselves.
Another study offers a piece of the explanation that is uncomfortable but useful. Researchers working with families living with brain injury described a caregiving bind: caregivers often hide how much they do, to protect the dignity of the person they care for. It is an act of love. It also makes the work invisible, and invisible work does not get asked about (Moore and Gillespie, Social Science & Medicine, 2014). Part of why no one asks may be that many of us have worked very hard to make it look as though there is nothing to ask.
One caregiver interviewed by the CBC put the cost of all this plainly: “I needed to be seen. I needed to feel that my feelings are legit.” (CBC Radio, Out in the Open)
Family Doesn’t Ask
One line got a lot of quiet nods: family doesn’t ask how you’re doing.
Within a family, the nicety often drops away entirely. Maybe it feels too formal. Maybe the expectation is that you will reach out if you are not okay. But reaching out is its own kind of ask, and as the group talked about last month in The Hardest Ask, asking on our own behalf is the hardest kind there is. So the people closest to the situation can end up being the ones who ask least.
What to do when someone does ask is where the conversation went next, in When Someone Does Ask.
Where We Have Been Before
- The Aftershock of Crisis or Loss, on how isolating it is when no one asks how you are really doing.
- The “Doing So Well” Disconnect, on being seen only in the good moments.
- Beyond the Caregiver Label, on wanting to be cared about as a whole person.
- The Symptoms No One Sees, on how much of caregiving never shows.
- When You Are Finally Seen, on what happens when someone does notice.